For First-Timers (or a Refresher for Veterans)
What is this?
Think of it as a combination of improv theater + costume party. There are planned events throughout the night as the story progresses, but there’s no script to read.
What happens at a murder mystery party?
The first act is pre-murder where people get to know one another, take part and witness planned confrontations/scenes, generally get a feel for the characters and situation. You’ll get to know your team and its relationship with the others. The second act is after the murder where you’ll be given new information to use as you wish and try to solve the mystery. There may be mini-goals for your character or team to strive for.
Do I need to stay in character the whole time?
At least until the murder is solved. It’s a very enticing thing for an introvert, or anyone who hates small talk at parties – you’re not you, so you can act as outrageous, silly, aloof, or crazy as you wish. After it’s all over, you can hang out and introduce your real self. In 2024, Ryan (Jen’s husband) said what he liked most about the party was “the mingling in character during the first act” and September added, “just hanging out in character was a blast.”
How long should I get a babysitter for?
The mystery part of the night goes from 7 to 11, and the after party goes til very late.
How flexible is my character?
Extremely. You can give yourself a whole backstory if you want. Last year, Amanda remarked, “I loved seeing everyone reveal who their characters were. Dr. Hilarius (Benita) making it clear she could hook anyone up that made an appointment with her. Judge Stonefist (Suzanne) absolutely living up to the name. Dramatic moments too, like Frankie (Rob) finding the loose heroin in Tommy’s (Daniel) basement and the fight between Vic (Sam) and Charlotte (Jess).” – I didn’t script ANY of that. Then Ryan commented, “Devin played so completely against type that he began experiencing the character as a kind of ethical dilemma.” Daniel continued this with “Devin’s paranoia about Communism was hilarious. As Act 2 got underway and I tried to rally people to find the fuses, he asked frantically “Is it the Communists?!” “Yes,” I said. “Communists are trying to burn down my jazz club. I don’t know why. But, Mr. Pembroke, we need your help to save American free enterprise!”” Again, I didn’t write or plan any of that. You can really go wild.
I have no idea what I’m doing.
That’s OK. You’ll be in a team with others who have done this before. You’ll have the same information as they do and you’ll work together to solve the crime. You can also choose to go rogue and strike out on your own. Last year, Chandra remarked, “The casual mingling really helped me an introvert ease into the whole thing and not feel awkward at all.”